Goldco vs. American Hartford Gold

Goldco and American Hartford Gold are reputable options for which gold IRA company to select. While they share similarities, such as their focus on gold investments, there are notable distinctions between them regarding platinum availability, minimum investment requirements, and educational resources.

Goldco stands out by offering the opportunity to invest in platinum alongside gold. This added flexibility allows investors to diversify their portfolios further. However, Goldco has a minimum IRA investment threshold of $25,000, which potential investors should consider.

On the other hand, American Hartford Gold does not provide the option to invest in platinum. This may be a drawback for those interested in including platinum in their precious metal holdings. However, an advantage of choosing American Hartford Gold is the absence of a minimum purchase amount. This can appeal to investors who prefer to start with smaller precious metals investments or have more flexibility in their initial contributions.

(I’ve put both of these companies on my top gold investment companies, so you are in good hands either way.)

To better understand these differences, it is advisable to delve deeper into each company’s specific features and benefits. Prospective investors can make an informed decision based on their unique investment goals and preferences by considering customer reviews, customer service quality, and overall reputation.

Goldco Overview

visit goldco

Established in 2006, Goldco Precious Metals is a well-established brokerage company in the precious metals industry. Its primary focus is assisting customers in setting up self-directed gold IRA accounts through gold IRA rollovers or direct funding. The gold IRA company offers many precious metals, including gold, silver, platinum, and palladium, gold and silver coins.

Goldco has a strong reputation for its exceptional customer service, professionalism, and reliability. Customer reviews frequently highlight the company’s commitment to personalized attention and support. Their dedicated customer service agents are readily available to address inquiries and offer assistance throughout the process.

Customers of Goldco can expect guidance in opening self-directed IRA accounts, funding their investments, selecting suitable physical precious metals IRAs, and facilitating the secure transfer of gold and silver products to custodial facilities. The company’s reputation extends not only to satisfied customers but also to recognition from industry regulatory bodies.

Goldco boasts impressive ratings, including an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, an AAA rating from the Business Consumer Alliance, and 4.8 out of 5 stars on both ConsumerAffairs and TrustLink. With an average satisfaction score of 4.8 out of 5 stars, Goldco has established itself as a trusted and reputable player in the industry.

American Hartford Gold Overview

American Hartford Gold

Founded in 2015 and headquartered in Los Angeles, California, American Hartford Gold is a precious metals gold IRA company. It has gained recognition for its outstanding customer reviews, commitment to buyback services, and price matching. The best gold IRA company specializes in assisting customers with traditional IRA account rollovers.

American Hartford Gold prides itself on its attentive and caring customer service. Customer reviews testify to the company’s dedication to providing a positive experience. It holds an impressive 4.9 out of 5 stars rating on TrustLink, an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, an AA rating from the Business Consumer Alliance, and 4.9 out of 5 stars on ConsumerAffairs.

American Hartford Gold focuses on self-directed precious metals IRAs while providing direct sales, offering a range of physical gold, silver, and platinum products. The reputable gold IRA company ensures that both new and experienced investors receive a comprehensive customer service experience they can rely on.

Rollover Options: American Hartford Gold and Goldco

American Hartford Gold provides a valuable service for individuals seeking to roll over various traditional IRA accounts, including 401(k) and IRA accounts. They assist customers with the necessary paperwork and funding to establish a new Precious Metals IRA account by transferring funds from their existing accounts. Customers can roll over the entire amount or a portion of their current traditional IRA accounts.

Similarly, Goldco Precious Metals also offers numerous opportunities for rollovers. They assist customers who wish to transfer funds from eligible traditional IRAs and retirement savings accounts into Precious Metals IRAs. Goldco supports the rollover process for a wide range of qualifying accounts, which include Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SIMPLE IRA, SEP IRA, 401(k), 403(b), Roth 401(k), and Roth 457(b) accounts.

Also check out Goldco vs. Noble Gold Investments.

Fees Information

Fee Information for American Hartford Gold:

American Hartford Gold does not provide detailed information about the fees associated with opening a Gold IRAs account or purchasing precious metals. The prices are subject to variation based on the account status and the value of the precious metals. If you invest a more significant amount, there is a higher possibility that annual storage fees will be waived.

Here are some general details about American Hartford fees:

  • The fees for setting up an account are not listed.
  • The fee structure is variable.
  • The fees for annual account storage are not specified. Some accounts may qualify for free storage every year.
  • There are no shipping fees mentioned.
  • The annual custodial fee is not listed.

American Hartford Gold does not specify the minimum investment requirement on its website. However, they offer the direct sale of precious metals for investors who do not have an IRA.

Additionally, American Hartford does not provide the cost of its products on its website.

Fee Information for Goldco Precious Metals

Goldco Precious Metals applies fees similar to those other reputable gold IRA companies charge. It provides a limited list of payments on its website. Although many prices are listed, some are subject to variation or not disclosed. The list provided is not exhaustive, and additional fees may be applicable.

Here are the fees listed by Goldco:

  • One-time retirement account setup fee: $50
  • One-time money wiring fee: $30
  • Annual maintenance fee: $80
  • Custodial yearly fee: $100
  • Minimum investment: $25,000
  • Cost of precious metals: Fluctuates based on market value.

Distinguishing Features of Goldco and American Hartford Gold

While Goldco and American Hartford Gold exhibit numerous similarities, notable distinctions set these two companies apart. Let’s delve into these differences:

1. Establishment Date

Goldco was established in 2006, demonstrating resilience by weathering the 2007-09 recession. This underscores the company’s ability to withstand challenging economic times and reinforces the value of gold IRA investing in precious metals. American Hartford, though founded in 2015, has managed to maintain stability during its relatively shorter time in operation. However, in terms of experience, Goldco’s longer tenure suggests a potentially broader range of expertise.

2. Depository Services

Goldco IRA exclusively partners with the Delaware Depository for precious metal IRA storage services. In contrast, American Hartford collaborates with the Delaware Depository and Brink’s Global Services in LA. This offers American Hartford clients greater flexibility in selecting a depository. However, neither company matches the versatility of Augusta Precious Metals, which partners with multiple holds nationwide.

3. Buyback Program

Goldco stands out with its robust buyback policy, guaranteeing to repurchase of precious metals at any time, regardless of prevailing prices. American Hartford Gold, in contrast, has a less effective buyback policy that lacks a buyback guarantee. If the buyback program is a critical factor, Goldco is the preferred choice.

4. Minimum Initial Investment Requirement

Goldco sets an initial investment requirement of $25,000, while American Hartford Gold has no minimum contribution amount. Starting with American Hartford Gold is more affordable and accessible, as you only incur standard charges such as storage, setup, and wiring fees.

5. Other Fees

Goldco appears more transparent with its fee structure, whereas American Hartford Gold lacks some specific details, requiring further research for clarity. Here is a breakdown of Goldco’s fees:

  • One-time setup fee: $50
  • One-time wire fee: $30
  • Annual maintenance fee: $80
  • Storage fees: $150 for segregated storage and $100

Choosing Between Goldco and American Hartford Gold

When considering the options of American Hartford Gold and Goldco Precious Metals for gold IRA investing, both gold IRA companies offer attractive features. They share similarities such as rollover opportunities, prompt delivery to secure custodial facilities, and a buyback program.

Both companies have comparable standings regarding customer ratings and recognition from industry regulatory bodies. However, the differences between them ultimately determine the superior choice.

American Hartford Gold falls short of providing transparent information on its website. It does not disclose a comprehensive list of fees or the minimum investment required to open a precious metals IRA account.

On the other hand, Goldco takes a more transparent approach by publishing a detailed list of fees. While there may be hidden fees, Goldco offers a clearer understanding of the upfront and annual costs investors can expect. Furthermore, Goldco explicitly states the minimum investment requirement for new investors.

Another advantage of Goldco is its extensive industry experience, spanning nearly a decade longer than American Hartford Gold, making it one of the oldest companies in the field.

Considering these factors, Goldco Precious Metals emerges as our preferred choice between the two options.

Suggested Reading:  Goldco vs. Birch Gold Group.

Conclusion – Which is Better?

Both companies are highly regarded in the precious metals industry, and choosing either would be a wise decision. They have received positive ratings from various sources, including websites, regulatory bodies, media outlets, and celebrities.

Moreover, both companies boast responsive and helpful customer support teams who can be reached via email, phone calls, and live chat whenever assistance is required.

However, Goldco appears to have certain advantages in terms of fee transparency, its buyback program, and its experience in the industry. While American Hartford Gold offers some variety in depositories, they still have room for improvement in their buyback program.

Considering everything, our recommendation leans towards Goldco as it provides a slightly more comprehensive package than American Hartford Gold.

Other Gold IRA Companies:

Tim Schmidt


Tim Schmidt is an Entrepreneur who has covered retirement investing since 2012. He started IRA Investing to share his expertise in using his Self-Directed IRA for alternative investments. His views on retirement investing have been highlighted in USA Today, Business Insider, Tech Times, and more. He invested with Goldco.