American Gold Exchange Review 2023: Scam Risk or Safe?

When it comes to precious metals, you want a trustworthy dealer. The American Gold Exchange (AGE) is a rare coin company specializing in different precious metals. It has a solid reputation for excellence in the field.

This comprehensive review will explore what sets AGE apart from competitors and why you should consider it for all your gold and silver coin investments. Whether you’re a seasoned investor or just dipping your toes in the market, we’ve covered you with the most up-to-date information.

Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!

The American Gold Exchange in a Nutshell

This leading national precious metals company from the United States was established in 1998. Dana Samuelson is currently steering the business toward its success in the market. AGE is one of the oldest companies selling and buying gold coins and other precious metals.

It has a vast inventory that includes everything from rare coins to the highest-quality gold-related products. You’ll find what you’re looking for to diversify your portfolio.

The American Gold Exchange sells certified and uncertified modern bullion coins and bars to customers. AGE also offers a unique selection of pre-1933 coins, which take investors back to a time before the abandonment of the gold standard.

Regarding costs, AGE strives to offer extremely low prices to its customers. As a leading precious metals dealer, it has strong connections and relationships.

This allows it to source silver coins and other precious metals at competitive prices. By passing these savings onto you, the American Gold Exchange ensures you get the best value for your investment.

In addition to its competitive prices, AGE’s team of experts is ready to assist you every step of the way. The knowledgeable staff can provide valuable insights and guidance, making your buying process smooth and hassle-free. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced investor, they can cater to all your needs.

Note that the American Gold Exchange buys and sells precious metals. It does not offer brokerage services to customers.

AGE Products and Services

AGE Products

Each item in its inventory is hand-selected by its expert team. This ensures you receive only the finest products. Whether you’re looking for gold coins, silver dollars, or rare coins, the American Gold Exchange has the selection to cater to your needs.

1. Gold Coins

This company specializes in various precious metals, with gold being its most popular item. From timeless classics to modern mints, you will find it all here.

2. Silver Coins

If you don’t want to buy gold, consider silver coins and bars instead. Such precious metals are cheaper than gold products. The American Gold Exchange offers high-quality silver bars at a competitive price.

3. Platinum Items

On the other hand, for those seeking something unique, the platinum collection is worth exploring. These rare and precious items can be a valuable addition to your holdings.

4. Palladium Products

Palladium has been a popular precious metal choice in recent years. The American Gold Exchange keeps up with the trend, offering palladium coins and bars for your consideration.

The website can provide a seamless browsing and buying experience. You can easily explore its almost limitless inventory and place your order confidently. AGE also offers direct sales to dealers, ensuring the products reach a wide range of customers.

Sell Gold and Silver Coins to the American Gold Exchange for Fair Market Value

Selling your old gold coins or other precious metals to AGE is a straightforward process designed to accommodate your preferences. Here’s a closer look at how it works:

1. Cash-on-Delivery Option: Quick and Hassle-free

If you’re looking for a fast and easy way to sell your gold, the American Gold Exchange has you covered with its cash-on-delivery option.

  • Contact AGE: Get in touch with AGE to start the selling process. You can reach out via a dedicated phone line, email, or its website.
  • Assessment: AGE will assess the value of your gold items and silver bars based on current market rates. This ensures you receive a fair and competitive offer. You can also sell platinum products and palladium coins.
  • Agree on Terms: Once the assessment is complete, you and AGE will agree on the terms of the sale, including the price offered for your precious metals.
  • Monetary Offer: AGE will offer you cash for your gold items. This can be an attractive option for those who prefer immediate payment.
  • Cash-on-Delivery: The company will arrange a cash-on-delivery (COD) service if you accept the offer. A representative will meet you in person, examine the gold items, and hand you the agreed-upon amount.

2. Payment by Check: A Convenient Alternative

Alternatively, you can receive payment by check if you prefer a more traditional payment method. Here’s how it works:

  • Contact AGE: Begin the selling process by contacting the company through your preferred communication method.
  • Assessment: Again, AGE will assess the worth of your valuable items based on market rates, ensuring a fair offer. You can choose to agree or disagree with the price quotes.
  • Check Payment: If you choose this option, the American Gold Exchange will issue a check for the agreed-upon amount through bank wire. This provides a secure and convenient way to receive payment for your gold valuables.

Both options —cash-on-delivery and payment by check— are designed to cater to your specific preferences. Unlike other dealers, AGE understands that selling gold jewelry or coins can be personal. It strives to make the process as convenient and efficient as possible.

This flexibility in payment methods is one of the reasons why this great service is popular. It’s especially appreciated by people looking to sell gold and silver products without the added paperwork and complexity often associated with such transactions.

Buy Precious Metals from the American Gold Exchange for a Fair Price

When you browse and shop on the American Gold Exchange website, you can confidently do so, knowing that you are dealing with a trusted and legitimate gold dealer.

Its online platform is your gateway to a vast selection of precious metals. The website spans gold and silver bars, bullion, coins, jewelry, and other valuable items. This wide variety ensures you can effortlessly diversify your investment portfolio.

The services extend across all 50 states in the United States, making the American Gold Exchange accessible to customers from coast to coast. This nationwide reach ensures your orders are promptly fulfilled and shipped in a timely fashion, regardless of location.

Over the years, AGE has forged robust relationships with its clients and industry partners. Its huge supplier network ensures that your package is handled diligently and delivered to you safely. The trust it has garnered within the market speaks volumes about its dedication to customer satisfaction.

Best of all, the American Gold Exchange offers return or replacement privileges for all certified coins. This reflects its commitment to protocols, making the buying process stress-free and enjoyable.

Open a Precious Metals IRA Account with the American Gold Exchange | Three Simple Steps

To kickstart the process, the first step is opening an account with a precious metals IRA firm, such as The Entrust Group.

1. Account Setup

You can quickly start this step from the comfort of your computer by visiting the firm’s website. During the IRA account setup, you must provide personal information to a custodian overseeing your funds.

After successfully opening your account, it’s time to inject funds into it. If you’ve chosen The Entrust Group as your IRA custodian, you can do this by sending a check to them. The statement should be equal to the fair market value of the precious metals you plan to invest in.

2. No Assets? No Problem

You don’t need to send anything if you don’t own any gold or silver items. Refraining from assigning a value to any precious metal at this stage is essential. The valuations are only estimates and won’t serve to enhance your IRA account’s growth potential.

3. Unlocking Investment Potential

Once you’ve funded your account, you can buy approved precious metals. This category includes coins, bars, and bullion, expanding your investment portfolio.

Always exercise due diligence when selecting a gold IRA company to ensure a trustworthy and reputable partnership.

The American Gold Exchange Guarantee on Precious Metals

Are you curious about how AGE goes the extra mile to safeguard its clients? Here’s an overview:

  • Precious Metals and Items Value Guarantee: It stands behind the value of all its precious metals and items. This assurance ensures that your investments keep their worth. When you deal with the American Gold Exchange, you can have peace of mind knowing that your assets are well protected.
  • Timely and Pristine Deliveries: The company takes punctuality seriously. It delivers every order to your doorstep in pristine condition. This commitment reflects its dedication to ensuring a smooth and secure experience.
  • Competitive Pricing Assured: You will receive a price quote that meets market standards. This approach ensures that you get the best value for your precious items.
  • Shielding Clients from Fraud: The American Gold Exchange goes the extra mile to protect its customers from fraudulent companies. Its strong reputation and many satisfied clients testify to its commitment to ethical practices. The company encourages dealer-to-dealer trading and direct sales to enhance its protection further.

The Pros and Cons of the American Gold Exchange: What You Need to Know

Before diving into your precious metal investments with the American Gold Exchange, it’s essential to weigh the advantages and disadvantages:


  • Extensive Affiliations: AGE boasts affiliations with many gold and silver dealers. This network provides its clients with access to a diverse range of items, enhancing your options as an investor.
  • Client-centric Relationships: The company has strong and lasting relationships with its clients and other dealers. This commitment ensures that clients receive dependable and prompt service, prioritizing customer satisfaction.
  • 24/7 Customer Support: AGE offers round-the-clock customer support through a dedicated phone line. This accessibility allows customers to seek help and answers to their questions. It reinforces the company’s commitment to excellent service.
  • Fair-value Policy: The American Gold Exchange maintains an honest policy of providing clients with fair value for precious goods. This ensures you receive the best possible return on your investments.


  • Limited Industry Recognition: AGE is not widely recognized in the market, which can pose challenges in sourcing the specific items you need for your investments.
  • Regional Focus: The American Gold Exchange operates as a regional business. It may not be as well-known or accessible outside the San Diego area. This regional limitation could affect the convenience of its services for clients in other states.
  • After-hours Phone Availability: The office phone lines at AGE do not respond after 4:30 p.m. This may cause frustration for clients who need help or information during non-business hours.

Does the American Gold Exchange Sell Certified Coins and Bars?

The American Gold Exchange stands behind the certification of all precious metals. Its unwavering confidence lies in your complete satisfaction.

When you partner with AGE, you can be confident that you are receiving the total worth of your investment. The company employs the services of the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) to certify the authenticity and quality of its metals.

These certified gold and silver coins adhere to the highest industry standards. Their value aligns with market fluctuations, ensuring your investments remain dynamic and responsive to market trends.

With AGE, you can trust that your investments are built on a foundation of integrity and quality certification. Buy and sell your certified rare coin from the American Gold Exchange for a competitive price.

AGE Reviews from Different Websites

The American Gold Exchange’s performance in various rating and review websites speaks volumes about the satisfaction of its clients. Here’s a summary of its impressive ratings:

  • Trust Pilot: The company has a 4.9/5 rating on Trustpilot. This is based on impressive 2016 reviews. AGE has delivered exceptional service that resonates with a multitude of clients.
  • Yelp: AGE boasts a stellar 5/5 rating on Yelp after garnering feedback from 20 reviews. 
  • Gold Dealer Reviews: This business maintains a commendable 4.7/5 rating on Gold Dealer Reviews. This shows its dedication to customer satisfaction extends across many platforms.

The high ratings across these reputable websites highlight AGE’s clients’ trust in its services. Such ratings provide valuable reassurance for people considering the company as their partner in certified and uncertified modern bullion coins.

Does the American Gold Exchange Scam Customers?

AGE is far from being a scam. In fact, it’s a reputable and trustworthy company. The business will keep your precious metals safe from fraudulent activities. Here’s why you can trust it:

1. Proven Track Record: AGE has a remarkable track record, with over 25 years of experience in the industry.

2. Secure Precious Metals: When you entrust your precious metals to AGE, you can be confident that they will be kept safe and secure, preserving your valuable investments.

3. Precious Metals IRA: As a first-time buyer, you can open a precious metals IRA. This lets you expand your investment portfolio with expert guidance.

4. Certified Coins: The PCGS certifies all AGE coins. This guarantees the authenticity and quality of its products.

Final Words

The American Gold Exchange has solidified its position as a trustworthy partner for seasoned investors. AGE also caters to those beginning their journey into precious metals.

Its dedication to fair pricing, certified bullion, and a secure transaction process highlights its commitment to transparency and customer satisfaction. AGE sweetens the deal with a free gold investing packet. This provides valuable insights to help you make informed decisions.

One notable advantage is its offering of pre-1933 coins. These offer a glimpse into metals’ historical significance and role in currency exchange. Also, AGE lets you open an IRA account. This enables you to grow your portfolio with its expertise.

The company offers a comprehensive and reliable platform for investments. Its extensive range of services, commitment to quality, and strong client relationships make it a notable choice in the industry. Your assets are in safe hands when you work with this business. 

Other Precious Metals Dealers:

Tim Schmidt


Tim Schmidt is an Entrepreneur who has covered retirement investing since 2012. He started IRA Investing to share his expertise in using his Self-Directed IRA for alternative investments. His views on retirement investing have been highlighted in USA Today, Business Insider, Tech Times, and more. He invested with Goldco.